ESTUDIANTES INDOCUMENTADOS

ESTUDIANTES INDOCUMENTADOS

A pesar de que los programas como DREAMERS y DACA ya se ven expirados y la nueva administración no tiene intención de volverlos a implementar, es cierto que existen una serie de derechos que todos los estudiantes indocumentados deberían conocer para no tener miedo y seguir estudiando. Para ello contamos en la entrevista con Melissa Taveras, responsable de FLIC (Florida Immigrant Coalition) que nos habla de todos los derechos que por ley, independientemente del estatus migratorio, poseen todos los estudiantes.

Providing Migrants a Safety Place?

Who is a migrant? Migrant is an individual who leaves his or her native homeland due to persecutions, violence, and economic shortages. Millions of people flee their countries, and emigrate to foreign countries seeking refugee or asylum. First of all, Cuban Seventh-day Adventist refugees escaped their homeland because of religious persecutions, and they migrated to the US during the Mariel boatlift, and sought refuge. For example, Ana Rodriguez had to repeat seventh grade three times because the final exam was on a Saturday, the sacred Sabbath day for Seventh-day Adventists. Also, Pastor Moreno’s father lost his job due to the fact that he converted to Adventism (Stepick p. 46). Then, thousands of Haitian refugees escaped their homeland worst dynasty dictatorship of the Duvaliers because of the fact that they suffered oppression and extreme poverty. Consequently, they migrated toward the US (Stepick p. 76). Last, tens of thousands of women and unaccompanied children migrated to the US from Central America northern triangle seeking asylum (Hiskey p. 1). For instance, the northern triangle region of Central America has three countries, and they are Guatemala, El Salvador, and Honduras. It is the most dangerous region in Latin America. Honduras is the most perilous of the three. Conflicts between organized crime dominate the penal system of the three countries (Hiskey p. 3).

Should the host countries receive the fleeing immigrants? Should the host countries protect the fleeing migrants? How should the host countries protect the fleeing immigrants? What should the host countries provide for the fleeing migrants? First, when Pope Francis addressed to the US congress in October, 2015, he said; “we are not afraid of the immigrants because we are immigrants, too. We should see the face of God in those fleeing people arriving at our borders”. Next, an United Nations non-refoulement international law prohibits a host country to send back immigrants to their native countries where their lives will be in danger, so it guarantees a refugee or asylum status to fleeing migrants escaping violence or persecutions. Last, the host countries should provide immigrants a safe place: a sanctuary where they peacefully live.

Jeanette Smith is the head executive of South Florida Interfaith Worker Justice in Miami. SFIWJ is a non-governmental organization. It works for an immigration reform, and advocates for a sanctuary congregations coalition among South Florida’s churches.

How can the houses of worship be involved in the sanctuary movement, or how can they be a sanctuary congregation, and why should they be a sanctuary congregation, and if they are sanctuary congregations; what are sanctuary congregations’ benefits for the community, and why are sanctuary congregations important for the community? How much do sanctuary congregations impact the context of reception for migrants, and how essential is their civic engagement when it comes to social justice for the migrant?

What is a sanctuary congregation, and why are sanctuary congregations important for the community? What are their benefits for the community? Based on SFIWJ guides and/or rules, a sanctuary congregation will protect immigrants. It will house strangers until it will meet them with their relatives, or it will find them a lawyer who will properly represent them. It will provide them with a mode of living, and involve with its protected ones so that they will feel as part of the congregation. For instance, there are seven ways to become a sanctuary congregation. They are long-term, short-term, and supporting a family in sanctuaries, accompaniment, rapid response, training other faith leaders, and private v. public congregations.

First of all, it is a long-term sanctuary. The congregation will host a family, and provide them with the essential mode of living such as a bedroom, bathroom, kitchen, food, and childcare. Then, it is a short-term sanctuary. It is just to house people for a few hours until they can reunite with their relatives, or they have a lawyer who represent them. Next, it is supporting a family in sanctuary. It means to support a family, and others’ congregations that help families as well. It economically provides families. It interacts with families so that families feel confident with the congregations. In addition, it is accompaniment. The sanctuary congregations’ members should accompany families to immigration courts. The sanctuary congregations should arrange vigils. Besides, it is the rapid response to families. It basically means to be ready to help migrants when they will need it like taking in and out children of school. Moreover, it is training other faith leaders or congregations. It is to train leaders who will want to be involved in helping immigrants. Last, it is private v. public congregations. It is not only considered the benefits to the immigrants’ families but also the costs to declare a sanctuary congregation.

Based on Woodard’s analysis of private v. public congregations, private Protestants opposes public Protestants. Private Protestants are southern evangelicals, and they are southern Baptists, Methodists, and Episcopalians. Their ideological free will is order and obedience. (Woodard p. 264). On the other hand, public Protestants are northern Congregationalists, Methodists, Unitarians, and Anglicans. Their ideals are pluralism (Woodard p. 270-271). They pursue to improve the quality of life of society (Woodard p. 267). Private Protestants advocate traditionalism while public Protestants look for social change (Woodard p. 281).

What is civic engagement? Why is civic engagement important for the community? What does civic engagement for the society? Civic engagement promotes voluntarism through charities in the community (Stepick p. 2-3). The concept of civic social capital develops four aspects. Those aspects are denomination, generation, leadership, and the context of reception (Stepick p. 8-13). The civic social capital reaches to society in three ways. They are bonding, bridging, and linking. First, it bonds to society by activities. Then, it bridges by volunteerism. Last, it links by involvement in politics in three different perspectives. First, it is in the local area by voting. Next, it is in the national view. Last, it is in the transnational perspective (Stepick p. 251-257).

How much do sanctuary congregations impact the context of reception for migrants? First of all, Cuban Seventh-day Adventist refugees experienced social rejection in Miami. They were Marielitos, and society stereotyped Marielitos as blacks, criminals, and homosexuals. However, they built their congregation as it was in Cuba (Stepick p. 47-48). They internally discriminated themselves because the first generation immigrants were conservatives, and they rejected their second generation because it was more liberal. For example, the first generation people were the congregation’s leaders, and they disgusted to have a second generation leader. Tracy Linares was recommended to lead the youth group, but she was not the kind of leader that the first generation liked (Stepick p. 56-57). On the other hand, Haitian refugees received acceptance in Miami. Thomas Wenski welcomed Haitian diaspora to Miami. He brought a Haitian priest, Monsignor Gerard Darbouze, and a French speaking priest, Charles Jackson, to effectively communicate with Haitians. He founded Notre Dame d’Haiti Catholic Center within St. Mary Cathedral, and advocated to construct Notre Dame d’Haiti Catholic Church. He started social service programs such as English as a second language classes, job placement counseling, health screenings, and legal assistance (Stepick p. 72-75). Last, Central American women and unaccompanied children were detained until they had their asylum hearings before an immigration judge (Hiskey p. 2). If they illegally crossed the US border, they did not have any right under the law to claim a refugee or asylum status. Therefore, it could be denied to them, and they could be deported to their countries of origin (Hiskey p. 5).

How essential is their civic engagement when it comes to social justice for the migrants? In Addition, Latin American Catholic Church has actively been advocating for immigrants. Latin American Episcopal Council (CELAM) founded Pastoral of the Human Mobility (SEPMOV) to overlook and protect migrants’ issues. It basically works with NGOs agencies. Catholic Church has been a voice in behalf of the immigrants. For example, the Conference on the Latin American Bishops in Puebla, Mexico in 1979 focused on migrations’ issues, and they looked for how could they help migrants based on the immigrants’ needs of food, shelter, rights, and employment? Like Latin American Catholic Church, the US Conference of Catholic Bishops provides social services for migrants through the Catholic charities Caritas. The Catholic Church bases on “receiving an immigrant is as receiving Jesus” (Phan p. 180-184). One of the proponent of the Catholic Church activism is Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio, now Pope Francis (Phan p. 187). Moreover, in Jupiter, Florida, a coalition of non-immigrants and immigrants community residents, the Catholic Church, and Florida Atlantic University’s staffs and students lobbied and formed El Sol Resource Center to improve the quality of life of migrants. For instance, St. Peter Catholic Church starts to offer Spanish speaking masses. Also, Catholic charities financially supported El Sol in its first year of operation (Lazo 4-5). El Sol has established social service programs to help immigrants to fulfill the American dream. It assists in job training, counseling, screenings, preventive care, health education, literacy classes, and legal services (Lazo p. 8-9). Ulysses arrived at El Sol as a teenage young man. He started to learn English. He finished high school, and completed college. He currently teaches English at El Sol to others like him (Lazo p. 11-12). Lastly, Reverend Robinson from Grace Lutheran Church in Miami Springs is curious about what is the original involvement in the sanctuary movement? His family in New York provided a sanctuary to a family; consequently, he really knows about it. He knows; what is it, and how does it function? He compromises to promote sanctuary congregation coalition in his annual retreat council in August, 2017. He has informally made a sanctuary among Miami Springs’ churches because All Angels Episcopal Church, Blessed Trinity Catholic Church, and Poinciana United Methodist Church pastors have created a teamwork with him. All of them work together. Maybe based on Woodard’s analysis of private v. public congregations, all of these churches are public because they work together to improve the quality of life of their parishioners.

As you can see, the civic social capital uses bonding to build bridging and linking to the society (Stepick p. 259), and so does the cities of Miami Springs and Jupiter, Florida. The city of Jupiter, Florida is not a sanctuary city, but it does not have any anti-immigrants ordinances (Lazo p. 7). Also, the city of Miami Springs, Florida is not a sanctuary city. Even though both of these cities are not sanctuary cities, both of them work with their communities together for the well-being of themselves. These make the cities of Miami Springs and Jupiter, Florida the best and safest place to live.

Works Cited
Stepick, Alex. Rey, Terry. Mahler, Sarah J. “Churches and Charity in the Immigrant City”. Rutgers University Press. 2009.
Hiskey, Jonathan. Cordova, Abby. Orces, Diana. Malone, Mary Fran. “Understanding the Central American Refugee Crisis”. American Immigration Council. 2016. https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org.
Lazo de la Vega, Sandra. Steigenga, Timothy. “Facing Immigration Fears: A Constructive Local Approach to Day Labor, Community, and Integration”. The Center for Migration Studies of New York. 2013.
Woodard, Colin. “American Nations: A History of the Eleven Rival Regional Cultures of North America”. Penguin Books. 2011.
Phan, Peter C. Padilla, Elaine. “Christianities in Migration: The Global Perspective”. Palgrave Macmillan US. 2015.

Migrants’ battle with the Child Welfare System

Currently in the United States, approximately six million American born children live with a parent or family member who is undocumented. These families live everyday in fear of being sent back to a land of violence and poverty that they no longer consider home. In the article by Steph Solis, an undocumented mother from Honduras admitted, “You’re trying to improve your life and provide your kids a better life. Now you’re in limbo with your kids because parents have to go to work. Kids are afraid because they don’t know if their parents will return home at the end of the day” (5). It isn’t unusual for this nightmare to become a reality, in fact, the Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s data revealed that between the year 2011 and 2013 about half a million-citizen children personally experienced and perhaps witnessed their parents arrest and deportation (6). When undocumented parents are faced with these circumstances they have a constitutional right to decide whether or not their children remain in their birthplace, the United States. The decision to separate, however, can cause the child to slip into Child Protective Services, especially if there isn’t a designated childcare provided prior to being detained or deported.

In 2011 about five thousand citizen children in foster care were reported with detained or deported parents (6). Unfortunately, this study reflects many immigration enforcement actions that occurred before parents considered or initiated any custody arrangements. Whichever the case may be, parting ways was a decision the parents had to make with their child’s well being in mind. The majority of these undocumented parents come from Central America, primarily from the “Northern Triangle” region. They are motivated to leave Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador because of the crimes that label these regions as having a “humanitarian crisis”. Oftentimes these migrants were victims of crimes that they can’t escape from if they stay in the country. The crimes are so violent that they still decide to risk their life to migrate to the United States (7). Being detained or deported is an involuntary act on the parents’ behalf yet it is portrayed in the child welfare system as a form of abandonment. This label can cause undocumented parents to be separated from their child permanently. Citizen children may be forcibly separated from their undocumented parents indefinitely due to these unorganized communications between the child welfare system and the immigration enforcement system. It is important to inform undocumented parents of the importance of assigning power of attorney right away in order to avoid the complication of their children being taken away from them by the state.

When confronted with a final deportation order, the initial concern of the parent is the safety of the child while dealing with this obstacle. However, if detained while away from the child, without arrangements for the child’s pickup, and without available documented family and friends, then the parent could be denied the option of choosing the custody or care for the child. Due to unarranged custody, the child will likely end up in foster care even if other undocumented family members are still living in the United States. Child Protective Services are obligated to handle this particular situation in this manner, even while undocumented family members are available because those relatives are also at risk of being deported at any moment (3). However, unnecessarily signing children into foster care when relatives are around increases significant financial responsibility to the United States. It was reported that the U.S spends approximately twenty two billion dollars a year on children in foster care, which translates to approximately forty thousand dollars each child (1). In addition, denying the child access to unauthorized relatives contradicts what research has shown to be emotionally and mentally healthier for the juvenile.

A child who is separated from a parent due to the parent’s deportation or detainment, he or she is more likely to develop mental health problems such as depression, anxiety, and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Jessica Papa is an example of the emotional and mental strain that is endured when a child is forcibly separated from a parent (4). She told her story on New America Media regarding the reasoning behind being diagnosed with depression. In detail, at the age of fifteen Papa’s mother was apprehended with handcuffs in front of her and younger brother, Omar, before school. The mother was detained in Miami for four years and then deported. During this time Papa experienced a loss of interest in school and began to skip class. At sixteen she dropped out of high school due to tension at home and extra responsibilities such as having to work fulltime. Soon after, at nineteen, Papa got pregnant and the absence of her mother hit her even harder. She reached out to a therapist who diagnosed her of depression. Even twenty years later, Papa still experiences recurring nightmares and frequent flashbacks (4).

In this same article, Myrna Orozco also informed readers of her own diagnosis. Orozco was also separated from a parent and was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder (4). Actually, PTSD is quite frequently diagnosed to children with at least one deported or detained parent. In fact, a study from the year 2013 to 2015 found PTSD to be more common in children that experienced a parent deported or detained (7). Interestingly enough, in 2016, significantly more children were reported with changes in their mental health, which included an increase in stress and anxiety due to their fear of family being deported.

Health risks have not only been recognized in children but also in babies before birth. Recognition of premature health risks was made after the Postville raid. The Postville raid was the largest raid in the United States, which occurred in Iowa at a slaughterhouse back in 2008. Unauthorized workers carried false identity papers so when arrested they were accused of identity theft, stolen social security numbers and so on. The majority of the workers were sent to prison for five months and then deported. Latinos, pregnant mothers included, in Iowa were distressed after these deportations. Pregnant Latina mothers were so distraught that the research conducted after the raid determined a twenty four percent increase in underweight infants compared to the year before. As for the white mothers after the raid, there wasn’t a significant change in the number of underweight babies. These complications are highly dangerous for the baby because it can result in infant death or long-standing health problems (7).

Additionally, the undocumented parents in the United States are generally filled with stress. After Child Protective Services are reached by law enforcement, the process of preserving parental rights can become difficult and sometimes even impossible to maintain. When parents are in custody of ICE they could be transferred to detention facilities as far away from home as even states away. Since the parents at this point can’t be transported anywhere for personal reasons they are unlikely to physically attend legal Child Protective Services proceedings and may have to resort to plead in court for phone privileges in order to attend via phone. It is important for every member to be present during these hearings because many important factors about the family’s separation are determined. For one, the court will decide whether or not CPS developed a plan that properly addressed the needs of the child and the family. It will also be determined whether the agency considered the parents and child’s needs when assigning services. Also, the degree of the family’s compliance is brought to light. The efforts made to assign the child with a family member including a sibling or the efforts provided for frequent visitation may also be examined. Overall the agency is heavily scrutinized during these hearings therefore it is important for all parties to be present to express specific concerns (4).

Throughout this time the parent is mostly in the dark and unaware of the child’s condition. In the meantime, Child Protective Services generate a plan to reunite the family, however, it’s a plan that doesn’t consider families in these predicaments. The plan falls through for the detained parents because it involves visitation, parenting courses, and secured housing. Each one of those options would implicate leaving the detainment center, an unrealistic task when ICE’s policies are considered. The consequence of being unable to participate in the reunification plan is experienced a year later when the Adoption and Safe Families Act enforces the permanency plan for the child. At times the reunification process may not occur due to overbearing fear on the parents behalf. In the Disappearing Parents Report, a judge told a story of an undocumented father, deported mother, and an infant child in foster care (7). The father was approved of the Child Protective Services site visit and was set to reunite with his baby. Sadly, the father was consumed with so much fear that he denied himself of being reunited. The Judge claimed that the father wanted to transport the child to where he lives but was afraid of being detained on the bus ride over to his child. The judge portrayed this case as “…really heartbreaking. It’s a real dilemma.” Even though reunification was prevented from occurring in this specific case, the plan is intended to reunite families and provide a sense of permanency for children in the presence of a new caregiver and a new home (4).

Generally, permanency policies include alternatives that result in reunited families, adopted children, placement with then relative now legal guardian, placement with an adult, or any other planned arrangements (4). The hearing for permanency options initially takes place after twelve months of the child’s new care, and again twelve months later to review and accept the plan for the child. If the undocumented parent is deported and doesn’t have his or her child’s custody for over fifteen months then Child Protective Services is required by law to petition to cease parental rights. There is an option for children to reunite with their parents before parental rights are terminated but it is only possible outside of the United States (4).

The research conducted on the child welfare system revealed some areas that require tweaking in a way that considers detained and deported immigrant parents. As of now, the parental rights of these unauthorized migrants aren’t protected. There aren’t policies that directly protect and assess the situation of these families; instead the outcome is heavily relied on the kindness of the people involved such as Child Protective Services caseworkers, judges, and attorneys. It was also noticed that caseworkers are mostly responsible for the direction the case goes. This is likely due to major decisions that are executed by them, which involve placement and reunification. The judges in these cases also aren’t provided legal guidance of how immigration status should be measured. This allows decisions to be made based on the views of each individual judge. The attorneys on the other hand, have been reported to rarely have direct contact with the detained parent (3).

To summarize, the process of citizen children being separated from undocumented parents and sent to foster care should be reassessed. It should be altered to consider obstacles that are enforced by ICE. Reflecting on the unique experience of immigrant families in America may influence organized communications between the child welfare system and the immigration enforcement system. Hard working families shouldn’t have to bear these distressing experience (3). Especially not if Child Protective Service and ICE have the power to show they really care about families. For now though, the best thing undocumented parents can do is stay informed.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Work Cited

  1. “Court Hearings for the Permanent Placement of Children.” State Statutes . N.p., Jan. 2016. Web. 27 July 2017.
  2. “Immigration raids tied to greater risk of underweight babies.” Reuters. Thomson Reuters, 01 Feb. 2017. Web. 27 July 2017.
  3. “ImmigrationProf Blog: Foster Care Process for U.S. Born Children to Deported Parents.” Law Professor Blogs Network. N.p., n.d. Web. 27 July 2017.
  4. New America Media,News Report, Anthony Advincula, Posted: Feb 18, 2014. “After Parents’ Deportation, U.S. Children Face Mental Struggles.” New America Media. N.p., n.d. Web. 27 July 2017.
  5. Steph Solis, Asbury Park (N.J.) Press. “Immigrant parents in N.J. fear separation from their kids.” USA Today. Gannett Satellite Information Network, n.d. Web. 27 July 2017.
  6. “U.S. Citizen Children Impacted by Immigration Enforcement.” American Immigration Council. N.p., 29 June 2017. Web. 27 July 2017.
  7. “Understanding the Central American Refugee Crisis.” American Immigration Council. N.p., 03 July 2017. Web. 27 July 2017.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I can hear Jesus’ indignant response to the AGs who want to deport ‘Dreamers’

EL PASO, Texas (RNS) Not many things made Jesus angry. He was the picture of patience and forgiveness even in the face of many serious human faults. But one thing often caused Jesus to fly off the handle — legalistic leaders.

While Jesus’ life and ministry may have taken place 2,000 years ago, now in my home state of Texas, legalists are placing the letter of the law ahead of the well-being and dignity of children and families.

On June 29, attorneys general from 10 states including Ken Paxton of Texas threatened in a letter to U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions to sue the Trump administration if it does not eliminate Obama-era protections that shield “Dreamers,” or undocumented immigrants who were brought to the United States as children.

The letter called on the administration to stop accepting new or renewing existing applications for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which President Obama created during his first term.

If these upholders of the law have their wish, Dreamers will no longer be protected from deportation.

The scribes and the Pharisees of his time drove Jesus to distraction. As he put it, “Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, you hypocrites. You pay tithes … and have neglected the weightier things of the law: judgment and mercy and fidelity. These you should have done, without neglecting the others” (Matthew 23:23). And as he told his disciples, “but do not follow their example. For they preach but they do not practice” (Matthew 23:3).

Are the roles of the scribes and Pharisees being played out again today? Paxton and the nine other attorneys general argue that it’s not enough to exercise our country’s legal prerogatives regarding immigration with the adults who have sought refuge within our borders. Must we go even further and also lay the heavy burden of the law on the children they brought with them? Will we wrench Dreamers from their schools, communities and the only homes they have ever known? Will we send them away because they are not “legal”?

Around 220,000 young people in Texas will be out of school and out of productive work: a classic formula to create the desperation that makes drug dealing and other crime appear to be the only option.

The leaders of Jesus’ day thought by fulfilling the minutiae of the law they could be righteous before God and, more importantly for them, appear righteous before human beings. Jesus answered that they should have practiced a higher law, that of justice and mercy and faithfulness. They should have imitated God’s compassion toward those forced by life’s circumstances to carry heavy loads. They should not have added to those loads with self-righteous insistence on the smaller points of the law.

When I hear this legalistic insistence upon every letter of our broken immigration law being carried out to this cruel degree, I can hear Jesus’ indignant response: “Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, you hypocrites.”

(Mark J. Seitz is bishop of the Roman Catholic Diocese El Paso)

 

Dispute Over British Baby’s Fate Draws In Pope and U.S. President

DDyGKkMUwAAmYOUBy DAN BILEFSKY and SEWELL CHAN

LONDON — Charlie Gard, who turns 11 months old on Tuesday, was born with an extremely rare genetic disease. He is blind and deaf, and he cannot breathe or move on his own. He suffers from persistent epileptic seizures.

Now the British infant is at the center of a global debate, drawing in the Vatican and President Trump, over what medical treatment, if any, he is entitled to receive, and who decides — his family, his doctors or the courts.

“These terrible decisions have to be made all the time,” said Jonathan D. Moreno, a professor of ethics at the University of Pennsylvania. “It is very unusual for a case like this to explode on the global stage. They raise difficult moral and ethical questions.”

The London hospital that is treating Charlie has asked permission to remove him from life support. His parents want to take him to the United States, where they believe an experimental treatment has a chance — however remote — of prolonging his life, even though the disease has no cure.

Three courts in Britain agreed with the hospital, as did the European Court of Human Rights, which last week rejected a last-ditch appeal by Charlie’s parents.

But Pope Francis and Mr. Trump have also weighed in, adding another dimension to an extraordinarily thorny bioethical and legal dispute that pits Britain’s medical and judicial establishment against the wishes of the child’s parents.

Judges in the case have acknowledged that the case highlights differences in law and medicine — and an American willingness to try anything, however unlikely the possibility of success — but have held that prolonging the infant’s life would be inhumane and unreasonable. The case echoes the one of Terri Schiavo, a Florida woman who was left in a persistent vegetative state after a cardiac arrest and was also the subject of a court battle.

A Vatican spokesman, Greg Burke, told Vatican Radio on Sunday that the pope had been following the parents’ case “with affection and sadness,” praying “that their desire to accompany and care for their own child to the end is not ignored.”

Italy’s top pediatric hospital, which is run by the Vatican, told the Italian news agency ANSA on Monday that it would be willing to take Charlie.

“We understand that the situation is desperate,” said Mariella Enoc, director of the Bambino Gesù hospital in Rome, noting that she had been in touch with British officials to signal a willingness to take the patient, the agency reported. “We are close to the parents in prayer and, if this is their desire, we are open to receiving their child at our structure for the time it will take for him to live.”

Mr. Trump, who was not known to have previously expressed a view on the matter, wrote on Twitter on Monday that if the United States could help, “we would be delighted to do so.”

Both the pope and the president stopped short of criticizing the court rulings or the hospital. Helen Aguirre Ferré, the director of the White House office of media affairs, said Mr. Trump had decided to speak out after he learned about “this heartbreaking situation.” Mr. Trump has not spoken with the family, she said, and does not want “to pressure them in any way.”

“The president is just trying to be helpful if at all possible,” she added.

Charlie was born on Aug. 4 with encephalomyopathic mitochondrial DNA depletion syndrome. He is thought to be one of only 16 children globally with the condition, the result of a genetic mutation.

Brendan Lee, the chairman of the department of molecular and human genetics at Baylor College of Medicine, who is not involved in the case, said in a phone interview that mitochondrial depletion syndrome has no cure. “Treatments involve different types of vitamin supplementation, but none have been shown to definitively work through studies,” he said.

Charlie’s parents, Connie Yates and Chris Gard, both in their 30s, have been waging a long and wrenching legal battle to keep him alive. They have raised more than 1.3 million pounds, or about $1.7 million, to help finance experimental treatment in the United States. There is also an international campaign, with an online petition, and there have been street protests in front of Buckingham Palace.

Charlie has been treated since October at Great Ormond Street Hospital, where doctors eventually decided that withdrawing life support was the only justifiable option. “Although Charlie’s parents have parental responsibility, overriding control is by law vested in the court exercising its independent and objective judgment in the child’s best interests,” the hospital said in a statement laying out its position.

Siding with the hospital were the High Court, on April 11; the Court of Appeal, on May 25; and the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, on June 8.

The High Court ruled that Charlie would face significant harm if his suffering were to be prolonged without any realistic prospect of improvement. Moreover, it said the experimental treatment, known as nucleoside therapy, would not be effective.

Money is not at issue; an academic medical center in the United States has offered to provide the experimental treatment. But a neurologist at the hospital, who has offered to oversee the treatment, told the court by telephone: “I can understand the opinion that he is so severely affected by encephalopathy that any attempt at therapy would be futile. I agree that it is very unlikely that he will improve with that therapy.”

Neither the hospital nor the neurologist was identified in court documents, and the White House has declined to identify either.

The Court of Human Rights ruled last week that the British courts had acted appropriately in concluding that “it was most likely Charlie was being exposed to continued pain, suffering and distress, and that undergoing experimental treatment with no prospects of success would offer no benefit, and continue to cause him significant harm.”

The case has drawn attention to important differences in legal systems.

Claire Fenton-Glynn, a legal scholar at the University of Cambridge who studies children’s rights, said that under British law, the courts were the final arbiter in medical disputes about the treatment of children.

She noted a 2001 case of conjoined twins, Jodie and Mary, who were born sharing an aorta. Separating the twins would lead to the death of the weaker twin; if they were not separated, both would die. A court ruled that the twins should be separated against the wishes of their parents; as expected, one died.

Courts in the United States are less inclined to get involved when there are disputes between parents and doctors, said Professor Moreno of the University of Pennsylvania, stressing that it was usually left to doctors, in consultation with parents, to decide on a child’s treatment.

He noted the case of Baby Jane Doe, who was born in 1983 with spina bifida and whose parents declined to approve surgery to prolong her life. That case led to a law, signed by President Ronald Reagan, that defined instances in which withholding medical treatment from infants could be considered child abuse, but also provided that in certain cases doctors and parents might choose to withhold treatment from seriously handicapped babies when such action would merely prolong dying.

G. Kevin Donovan, the director of the Pellegrino Center for Clinical Bioethics at Georgetown University Medical Center and a professor of pediatrics, said that in the United States, if parents insisted on continuing life-prolonging treatment against a doctor’s advice, the child would simply be transferred to another institution willing to comply with the parents’ wishes.

“It doesn’t seem to be a supportable position morally or ethically,” he said of the stance taken by the hospital in London, adding that what is legal and what is ethical are not always the same.

In the Schiavo case, her husband, who was her legal guardian, wanted to have her feeding tube removed, but her parents disagreed, setting off a seven-year fight that ended in 2005, after courts ruled in the husband’s favor. Life support was removedfrom Ms. Schiavo, who died at 41.

In that case, too, the pope, then John Paul II, and the president, George W. Bush, weighed in. Mr. Bush signed an act of Congress allowing federal courts to intercede in the case. But their interventions did not ultimately affect the outcome.

There was no immediate response to Mr. Trump’s statement from Charlie’s parents, who last week appeared to accept the finality of the courts’ rulings. Photographs of the couple sleeping with their sick child have circulated on social media recently.

“We are really grateful for all the support from the public at this extremely difficult time,” Ms. Yates said on Friday. “We’re making precious memories that we can treasure forever with very heavy hearts. Please respect our privacy while we prepare to say the final goodbye to our son Charlie.”

There was also no immediate reaction from the hospital.

“In Charlie’s case we have been discussing for many months how the withdrawal of treatment may work,” the hospital said. “There would be no rush for any action to be taken immediately.” It added that it would consult the family and that “discussions and planning in these situations usually take some days.”

Dispute Over British Baby’s Fate Draws In Pope and U.S. President

How attitudes about immigration, race and religion contributed to Trump victory

 Chief correspondent June 13

How attitudes about immigration, race and religion contributed to Trump victoryThe story of President Trump’s victory over Hillary Clinton has been analyzed and reanalyzed, told and retold since November. Is there more to add? The short answer, based on four reports released on Tuesday, is yes, and what the reports say is provocative.

The reports debunk some of the assertions of why Trump won — his criticism of free-trade agreements apparently was not as big a factor as some have suggested — while focusing on the specific role that race, religion, immigration and national identity played in the outcome and particularly how those issues may have influenced voters who switched to Trump after supporting President Barack Obama in 2012.

One of the reports notes that while those factors played a more significant role in 2016 than in 2012, in large part because Trump highlighted them, the ground was already shifting on those issues before Trump. If these issues continue to remain prominent in the national debate, they could further alter the alignment of American politics.

The reports are the first produced by the Democracy Fund Voter Study Group, which comprises 20 analysts from think tanks or other institutions across the ideological spectrum. Driving forces in assembling the project were Joe Goldman of the Democracy Fund and Henry Olsen of the Ethics and Public Policy Center.

The findings are based on online surveys, including one after the election with a sample of 8,000 people who had participated in other such surveys in 2011, 2012 and mid-2016. The surveys were conducted by the firm YouGov.

The authors of the reports approach the implications of what happened in 2016 from slightly different angles, examining the appeal of candidate Trump, the multifaceted coalition that came to support him, political divisions that continue between and within the parties, and how certain issues came to prominence in 2016.

John Sides, a political scientist at George Washington University and editor-in-chief of the Monkey Cage blog hosted by The Washington Post, directly confronts the role of race, religion and immigration and concludes that “attitudes about immigration, feelings toward black people and feelings toward Muslims became more strongly related to voter decision-making in 2016 compared to 2012.”

Sides argues that, even before 2016, there was “an increasing alignment between race and partisanship” and among whites there was “an increasing division based on education,” with non-college-educated whites moving away from the Democratic Party, especially after the election of Obama in 2008.

“The shifts among white people overall and white people without a college degree occurred mostly among white people with less favorable attitudes toward black people,” he writes. “No other factor predicted changes in white partisanship during Obama’s presidency as powerfully and as consistently as racial attitudes.” But he also notes that there also were clear divisions between white Democrats and white Republicans in their evaluations of Muslims and their attitudes toward immigration.

Economic stress also was a factor, with those who expressed negative views about the economy in 2012 “more likely to express key negative cultural attitudes in 2016,” according to a news release summarizing the findings.

Partisan loyalty was high in 2016, with 86 percent of Obama voters siding with Clinton and 89 percent of Mitt Romney’s voters supporting Trump. But Trump won a bigger share of those who had backed Obama than Clinton won among those who supported Romney. Had Clinton won a similar level of support from Romney defectors that Trump won among Obama defectors, she probably would be president, Olsen said, based on his analysis of the findings.

Sides examined possible reasons for those who switched from Obama to Trump. He found that there was “no statistically significant relationship between trade attitudes and vote choice in either election [2012 or 2016]. Nor was the widely discussed issue of economic anxiety more important in 2016 than in 2012.

Even before the 2012 election, Sides writes, a substantial number of white Obama supporters had views about Muslims, blacks and immigration that were less favorable. What did change between 2012 and 2016 was the increased significance in voters’ minds of issues about immigration and attitudes toward blacks and Muslims, among whites both with and without college degrees.

Even among GOP primary voters, those who backed Trump had less favorable attitudes toward Muslims and were more likely to say that immigration by foreigners should be made harder, according to data offered in a paper by Robert Griffin and Ruy Teixeira of the Center for American Progress. This was even more the case on immigration among those voters who switched from Obama to Trump.

“Those who held views of immigrants, Muslims, minorities and feminist women as the undeserving ‘other’ were particularly susceptible to Trump’s appeal in both the primaries and general election,” they write.

Emily Ekins of the Cato Institute provides a typology of the Trump coalition. She labels his core constituency as “American Preservationists” who comprise about a fifth of his supporters, and are less loyal Republicans than are other Trump voters. They lean economically progressive, think the political systems are rigged and have “nativist immigration views and a nativist and ethnocultural conception of American identity.”

About 1 in 3 Trump supporters are “Staunch Conservatives.” Ekins writes that they are “steadfast fiscal conservatives, embrace moral traditionalism and have a moderately nativist conception of American identity and approach to immigration.”

“Free Marketers,” a quarter of Trump supporters, hold more moderate-to-liberal views on race and immigration and supported Trump primarily because of their dislike for Clinton. “Anti-Elites,” about a fifth of the Trump coalition, are motivated by a belief that the political systems are rigged but take a more moderate position on immigration, race and national identity. She labeled a small fraction of his supporters as “The Disengaged” and said they feel unable to influence political and economic institutions.

Lee Drutman of the New America think tank writes that, by making issues related to national identity more prominent, Trump was able to attract economically liberal but socially conservative voters who had backed Democrats previously.

“Trump’s candidacy has brought more economic liberals into the Republican Party, moving the party’s center of gravity on these issues to the left,” he writes. “Trump has also moved the party to a much more nativist position on questions of national identity,” adding that these shifts are creating strains with the GOP coalition.

Although divided on some important economic issues, particularly the issue of income inequality, Republicans and Democrats are less divided on economics than they are on cultural and national identity issues. Supporters of Clinton and of Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) are less divided on issues than are Republicans, with the main difference being “about attitudes toward the establishment and the existing order than it is about specific issue positions.” One exception is trade policy.

Drutman notes that Trump has made clear he intends to put a priority on the issues that helped elect him, from his proposed travel ban that is now in the courts to crackdowns on illegal immigrants. He argues that this could further realign the parties, with Democrats pressured to move further left on these issues. Republicans, meanwhile, could be forced to shift toward those Trump voters, which could “further isolate remaining conservatives with moderate positions on immigration.”

Newest travel ban worries Central Florida Muslims

Rasha MubarakIbtihal Ibrahim was hoping that she had heard the last of President Donald Trump’s travel ban singling out Muslim-majority countries when it was struck down in court.

But now that a modified version has gone into effect, she said she is sad that her relatives in Sudan — and people in all six countries — may not have the chance she had to come to America.

“I really don’t understand the emphasis on the travel ban, a focus on keeping others out when we could work together,” said Ibrahim of Orlando, who is from Sudan but has lived in the U.S. for more than four decades.

The current version of the travel ban did not create the airport chaos that ensued during the first ban in January, when people were detained and deported and thousands of visas were canceled before it was struck down in court.

Even so, Central Florida Muslim organizations have been holding emergency sessions where people can talk to immigration lawyers to try to understand the rules and learn their rights.

The 90-day ban covers Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, Syria and Yemen. The Trump administration has said the nations have ties to terrorism and that it needs that time to evaluate security vetting procedures to protect Americans. In addition, refugees from any country are barred for 120 days.

Central Florida Muslims say they feel unfairly judged.

“Going after a single religion and saying to them they are not welcome in the United States and excluding people on the basis of religion is deeply troubling,” said Imam Abufarah Helmi Elagha, executive director of the American Muslim Leadership Center near Kissimmee.

Rasha Mubarak, a spokeswoman for the Central Florida chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, said some Muslims are afraid to leave the U.S. even if they’re not from the countries that were singled out because they fear other nations could be added.

“We have to prove this is a condemnation of a religion,” she said. “This is not a case of extreme vetting. We call on the administration to withdraw these arbitrary guidelines.”

The original version of the travel ban, signed by Trump on Jan. 27, included Iraq. The order indefinitely barred Syrian refugees and gave preference to refugees who were religious minorities facing persecution.

The U.S. Supreme Court in June allowed the government to reinstate a limited version of the ban, with an exception for foreigners with a “bona fide relationship” to Americans or American entities. The court is expected to hear a challenge to the ban in the fall.

The Trump administration interpreted the order to allow people with close family in the U.S., including parents, spouses, children, adult children and their spouses, siblings and in-laws. People with employment and university admission also would qualify. People engaged to Americans were added to the list in the hour before the ban took effect.

Grandparents, grandchildren, aunts, uncles, nieces, nephews, cousins, brothers- and sisters-in-law were not included, leading immigration advocates and others to decry the rules.

Dr. Shakil Ahmed, chairman and president of the American Islamic Community Centers in Longwood, said the ban has again created an excuse for Islamophobia that has intimidated some Muslims, including everyone from recent immigrants to established business owners and professionals. Women who wear the hijab, a head covering, are among the most vulnerable, he said.

“We don’t just want to be looked upon as someone who is different,” said Ahmed, a medical doctor. “We belong to the fabric of society.”

The state of Hawaii and immigrant groups that won lower court injunctions against the ban have said the administration is violating the Constitution by targeting Muslim-majority countries. They say the president has focused on them as part of his campaign promise to suspend all Muslim immigration.

U.S. Rep. Darren Soto’s office has received only one inquiry from a constituent concerned about the current ban — a University of Central Florida student whose girlfriend is scheduled to return from Iran at the end of July, district director Alex Barrio said.

Most of the people affected by the original ban were on visas, and that portion of the edict has been eliminated, said Barrio, whose boss represents southeast Orange County, all of Osceola and half of Polk.

Nonetheless, “We remain greatly concerned about the ban and are opposed to it,” said Soto, a Democrat.

Orlando immigration lawyer Nayef Mubarak, who advised people at forums at the American Muslim Community Centers and the Muslim Academy of Greater Orlando, questions why Trump hasn’t revamped security procedures since he’s been in office instead of relying on the ban that some say is politically motivated.

“I think the biggest thing we’re seeing is confusion,” he said. “I think it’s confusion and a little bit of fear.”

For Orlando resident Sarah Elbadri, the issue boils down to seeing other people denied the American dream she pursued when her parents brought her to the U.S. when she was 4 years old.

“This should not be a part of how we create policy,” said Elbadri, who is running for an Orlando City Commission seat in November.

ACLU, UM Law Clinic, Sue Miami-Dade County Over Immigration Policy on Behalf of Unconstitutionally-Detained U.S. Citizen

ACLU, UM Law Clinic, Sue Miami-Dade County Over Immigration Policy on Behalf of Unconstitutionally-Detained U.S. Citizen

July 5, 2017

MIAMI, FL – The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Florida, with the University of Miami School of Law’s Immigration Clinic and the law firm of Kurzban, Kurzban, Weinger, Tetzeli & Pratt, P.A., have filed a federal lawsuit against Miami-Dade County over its policy of detaining people without a warrant for immigration authorities.

The lawsuit was filed on behalf of an 18-year-old U.S. citizen who was detained under the policy despite being a citizen, and challenges Miami-Dade County’s policy of detaining people beyond the end of their criminal custody solely for a suspected civil immigration violation.

“We warned the county about the dangers posed by the premature decision to cave in to the Trump administration’s anti-immigrant threats,” stated ACLU of Florida immigrants’ rights attorney Amien Kacou. “Miami-Dade County has long prided itself on being a place welcoming to immigrants, and should honor that legacy by joining other cities large and small across the country in refusing to serve as tools of overzealous immigration enforcement policy.”

Adopted by Miami-Dade Mayor Carlos Gimenez on January 26, 2017, the immigration detainer policy violates the U.S. Constitution, including the prohibition against unlawful seizures under the Fourth Amendment and the guarantee of due process under the Fourteenth Amendment, according to the filing. Florida law also prohibits jail officials from detaining people for civil immigration purposes.

Miami-Dade County has been detaining people in jail for federal immigration enforcement officials ever since President Trump threatened in January to cut off funding for cities deemed “sanctuary cities.” After the County Commissioners voted in February to collaborate with immigration authorities, however, the Trump Administration clarified that only cities that violate federal law would be at risk of losing federal money. Although the County no longer faces loss of federal funding, the Commission has not adopted a new policy on immigration detainers.

The plaintiff in the lawsuit, 18-year-old Garland Creedle, has been a U.S. citizen since birth. Despite this, Creedle was held overnight to begin immigration proceedings against him under the county’s detention policy, following a March 2017 arrest over an alleged domestic dispute for which no charges were filed. Although Creedle was entitled to be released immediately upon posting bond, Miami-Dade officials held him in jail based on the assertion that he is a “removable alien.”

The lawsuit, which names Mayor Gimenez and the county itself as defendants, seeks an order declaring the mayor’s directive on immigration detainers invalid and Mr. Creedle’s detention unconstitutional. It also seeks compensatory damages.

A copy of the complaint is available here: http://aclufl.org/resources/creedle-v-gimenez-complaint/

Haitians Get Six Months of Protection from Deportation

Image result for tps miami herald

Haitians will receive six more months of TPS protections before it seems they may have to return to Haiti.

Almost 60,000 Haitians residing in the United States were told in May that they have six more months of immigration protections. Haitian refugees are in the United States under the designation of Temporary Protected Status (TPS). Many in Haiti were granted TPS due to the severe Earthquakes that devastated the region almost seven years ago.

Secretary John Kelly relayed that although the status has been extended, the six month period should be used to arrange travel and for Haiti to prepare for the influx of Haitians back to Haiti.

Senator Bill Nelson warned Secretary Kelly that six months was simply not enough time for Haiti to “absorb 60,000 of its people back.” Immigrants rights activists echo that sentiment. Marleine Bastien, executive director at FANM, said that this extension is not enough. “Six months, and then what? The conditions in Haiti are horrible enough to extend TPS for 18 months to 24 months,” Bastien stated.

Haiti’s economy is still suffering from the devastating impacts of those Earthquakes and several hurricanes that have hit since. In addition, some organizations given money to help Haiti have contributed almost nothing to relief efforts. These concerns propel anxieties within Haitian communities within the US who are not sure if they’ll even have housing if they are forced back to Haiti. “There are still tent cities from the Earthquake” Representative Fredericka Wilson stated.

Recently, Secretary Kelly visited the backyard of one of the largest Haitian Diasproric communities, South Florida. That visit was held at Florida International University and was met with protests. Thomas Kennedy, a local activist and organizer, stated that many in the Miami community want the Trump administration to know that TPS recipients from Haiti and other countries are an asset to Miami, not a detriment.